Skip to main content

 

Reading Assignment: Chapters 5-8  The Outsiders

 

Writing Assignment: Write a paragraph or two explaining how Ellen Raskin's The Westing Game and Cynthia Kadohata's kira-kira are similar or different in their view of America's ability to assimilate different ethnic groups. Do they both believe that the U.S. has been able to create the "brotherhood [sisterhood] from sea to shining sea" celebrated in the song "America The Beautiful," which plays such an important role in Raskin's book? Please open with a general statement about how they are similar or different before citing any events, characters, or dialogue from either novel.

Last edited by Laraine
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

America’s ability to assimilate different ethnic groups is both represented directly or indirectly in Ellen Raskin’s The Westing Game and Cynthia Kadohata’s kira-kira. While The Westing Game talks about a bunch of heirs working together to solve a puzzle—who kill Sam Westing, the president of Westing Paper Product Corporation, the kira-kira mainly focus on two Japanese girls’ glittering sisterhood and their life in the United States. Although the latter one seems to convey some bad impressions of what Japanese went through in America, generally, the two works both reflect what we called benevolent assimilation in the U.S., which makes this country unique and vibrant. For instance, in the The Westing Game, people from a variety of backgrounds live together, meet together, and work together toward a common goal, which is finding out the true murderer of Westing using as many resources as they could. There are the Hoos who come from China. There is a female Judge J. J. Ford, who is proud of her African-American heritage. They all changed and even transformed tremendously during their time with others. An example would be the change toward Chinese food and culture. At first, only a few go to eat in Mr. Hoo’s restaurant despite a lot of great deals are being promoted. However, as the story goes on, due to their connections of living in the same apartment, parties and meetings started to be held at that restaurant, allowing people to get to know some traditional Chinese cuisine, like striped bass. Later, Grace Wexler, who shows a great passion of running this restaurant, joined their restaurant and renames it as Hoo’s On First, which achieves an astonishing success. The restaurant even attracts some famous athletes to eat there. Eventually, instead of being a house decorator, who Grace wished to be before, she creates a chain of Chinese restaurants. Yet Hoo starts to concentrate on his patent on shoes innersoles, and his business is successful. They two, who belongs to different ethnic groups, significantly transform themselves when living together. Living together allows them to know about new elements brought by each other, and further discover their passions. What is also worth-mentioning is that the book is centered around Sam Westing, who to some extent represents the America. Sam Westing is a second generation of immigrants, while America is exactly formed with immigrants from across the globe. The heirs, who come from a variety of different backgrounds, are actually like the residents and citizens of U.S. Also, Westing surely loves all of his heirs, as the end of the book mentions. Considering the whole book, I figure that the thing he actually loves is exactly no more than the diversity of his community. While The Westing Game mainly focuses on how diversity contributes to each member of their community, Kira-Kira describes how much things different people, especially children, shared in common. Lynn and Amber’s friendship is an excellent example of this. Lynn, the elder Japanese girl, and Amber come to be really good friends, who nearly stay together all the time. As their original ethnic group lives so far away from each other, it’s easy to form all kinds of misconceptions and stereotypes. However, when they live and study in the same place, they still have a lot in common. They both like to be a model in the future, so they try to practice walking like the way models usually do. They even put books on their heads. In addition, they also talk about boys and all other things they would like. Katie, the younger sister, also owns the same experience. She met an American girl Silly, who later becomes the little Japanese girl’s buddy, at the parking lot of the hatchery, where Katie’s mother works. From then on, Silly often comes to Katie’s house for fun. The thing is that they just act as if there is no barrier between their racial groups; even it is just after World War II.
From Lewis. I do believe in America, there’s a strong assimilation to different races. America makes them together, and it is showed clearly or impliedly in Kadohata’s Kira-Kira and Raskin’s The Westing Game. I think in these two novels, they both talked about some immigrants in States. While Kira-Kira was mainly about a Japanese family’s life in foreign land, The Westing Game was talking about a bevy of heirs from distinct backgrounds. In Kira-Kira, Katie’s family immigrated to America from Japan. So there were some culture conflicts in their life, and at that time, WW2 just finished, Japanese Americans were stereotyped and even ignored. They got unequal standard. Although there were so many problems left over by history after WW2, it couldn’t prevent the new generation from communicating. Just like Lynn and Amber or Katie and Silly. Although there’s a large gap between the western culture and eastern culture, they also could find the same topic or sameness. Lynn and Amber both wanted to be modern, they always did something odd and fancy. And while Lynn got illness seriously, Katie was growing up gradually. Katie became mature and independent. She found Lynn was not that omnipotent in some ways. And she was speechless when she stayed with her Lynnie sometimes, or even there were arguments. So Katie get on with Silly very well day by day. As for The Westing Game, also, there were many out lander here. For example, Madame Hoo, who stole to pay for her return to China and at first she spoke almost no English. However, later on, with her patner, Jake Wexler’s help, she learned lots of words and phrases. Another example, Judge J.J. Ford is the Judge who is proud of her African-American heritage and background. So there were so many distinct characters mixed together and made a fantastic mixture. I do think they were assimilated by American culture. Right, American culture is very diversified and it globalize the citizen. I mean America just like a big family, it has mixed all kinds of elements and it would like to assimilate much more elements of culture that these two books showed us.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×